2. Allochromatic minerals: the colour is borrowed
Here you'll find most of the more commercial gems. In their pure form they would be colourless, but tiny traces of other elements —sometimes one part in a million— tint the crystal. Because the impurity varies from one deposit to another, a single mineral can display many different colours.
The perfect example is quartz, the star of so many display cases:
- Amethyst: violet, from traces of iron exposed to the ground's natural radiation. It's the same iron that under other conditions gives golden tones, just arranged differently within the crystal.
- Citrine: golden to amber, also from iron but in a different state; in fact, amethyst and citrine are chemically almost twins and sometimes coexist in a single two-tone crystal called ametrine.
- Smoky quartz: brown to grey, from natural radiation acting on small impurities.
- Rose quartz: its soft pink shade is due to traces of other elements and to tiny internal fibres, which sometimes create a delicate star effect when light strikes it head-on.
- Rock crystal: transparent, quartz with hardly any guests to colour it.
The same happens with beryl: colourless in its pure state, it becomes green emerald with chromium, blue aquamarine with iron, pink morganite with manganese, or yellow heliodor, also with iron. It's astonishing to think that gems with such different names are, deep down, the same mineral with different guests inside.
Something similar —and almost poetic— happens with corundum: the same mineral is red ruby when it carries chromium, or blue sapphire when it carries iron and titanium. In other words, a ruby is nothing more than a red sapphire. And fluorite takes the prize for variety: it can appear violet, green, blue, yellow, pink or colourless, sometimes with several bands of colour in the same piece, which has made it one of collectors' favourites.
The big lesson: colour alone is not enough to identify an allochromatic mineral.
A green could be emerald, tourmaline, peridot, jade or fluorite; a red could be ruby, garnet or spinel. That's why mineralogists never trust colour alone: they also look at hardness, lustre, crystal shape and other properties. Colour is the first invitation, not the last word.